The works of the six recipients of the 2024 Pécsi József Photography Grant offer glimpses of six possible states in the complex and constantly changing relationship between the photographic image and reality. More than simply bringing together the individual artistic positions in an exhibition of the grant recipients’ work, States of Reality also seeks answers to current questions, such as what processes reality must undergo to become an image within each artist’s practice.
For a long time, photography was regarded as one of the most convincing forms of evidence of reality, and its privileged relationship to the real seemed to be one of the medium’s defining characteristics. For decades, however, photographic theory has questioned whether this relationship can, in itself, guarantee truth. In contemporary photography, documents, personal memory, research, performance, optical constructions, staged images, and artificially generated imagery all belong to the same visual culture. Yet their relationship to reality remains far from straightforward.
By presenting six distinct artistic positions, the exhibition traces a path from observation to the generated image. András Zoltai (lyrical documentary photography / expanded documentary practice) still begins with the observed world but reshapes the documentary image through personal memory and metaphorical meanings. Olivér Lantos (research-based subjective documentary photography) turns the experience of social reality into a subject of research, bringing interviews related to the subject he has identified and associative images together into a visual system. Boglárka Éva Zellei (performative post-documentary photography / feminist and participatory photography) transforms documentable reality into an embodied and performative experience. Krystyna Bilak (medium-reflexive photography / expanded photography) investigates vision itself and the mechanisms of photographic representation. Benedek Bognár (conceptual, constructed post-documentary photography / metaphotography) questions the credibility of the image and the ways viewers’ interpretations can be manipulated. In Hanna Rédling’s work (autobiographical post-photography / expanded photography), the boundaries between photographed and constructed images, as well as between analog and digital processes, become increasingly blurred, bringing 3D imaging and physical objects into a shared visual system.
The numbered questions assigned to the grant recipients’ works do not imply a hierarchy of quality or artistic development. Instead, they follow a proposed dramaturgical structure, presenting six possible relationships between reality and the photographic image that “captures” it, from observation to the generated image. This sequence also seeks to convey the gradual shift in the contemporary photographer’s position, away from the classical model based on representing reality and toward the independent construction of images. Through these six practices, visitors can follow one possible trajectory in the relationship between photography and reality: from Zoltai’s documentary starting point, through Lantos’s research-based, associative visual system, Zellei’s performative image-making, Bilak’s examination of the medium itself, and Bognár’s photographic skepticism, all the way to Rédling’s hybrid post-photographic world, which brings together analog and digital processes with 3D imaging.
The spatial arrangement follows this conceptual trajectory. The questions assigned to the individual artists help visitors follow both the sequence of ideas and the corresponding route through the exhibition. Rather than separating the different positions, the numbering marks stages in a process in which the questions assigned to the artists gradually lead visitors from one toward the next.
These artistic positions give rise to a series of questions: 1. What Can Be Documented? 2. How Does a Social Experience Become an Image? 3. Who Speaks When We Present Someone Else’s Story? 4. Do We See What Is in Front of Us? 5. Why Do We Believe What We See? 6. Do We Still Need Reality to Make a Photograph?
Looking at the photographs in the first section of the exhibition, we can still readily say, “This happened.” By the time we reach the sixth section, however, the question itself becomes uncertain: what, if anything, had to happen for the image before us to come into existence?
In the end, all six artistic practices return to the same fundamental question: what relationship does the photographic image have today to what we call reality
Mónika Zsikla